Mahoe Bay – Ironshore P O, Montego Bay, Saint James, Jamaica
resort comparison guide

Riu Palace Jamaica vs Hotel 39 Jamaica

Choosing between Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica and Hotel 39 Jamaica? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, dining, amenities, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which stay is the best fit for your Jamaica getaway.

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica resort
Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica
Adults-Only • Mahoe Bay • All-Inclusive

Best for couples and friends who want an 18+ all-inclusive beachfront resort in Montego Bay with pools, dining, and resort amenities built into the stay.

Hotel 39 Jamaica resort
Hotel 39 Jamaica
Montego Bay • Hotel-Style Stay • Flexible Base

Better for travelers who want a more straightforward Montego Bay hotel stay and do not need the full adults-only all-inclusive resort setup.

Quick Verdict: Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica vs Hotel 39 Jamaica

If you want an adults-only, all-inclusive beach resort with multiple restaurants, swim-up bars, 24-hour room service, and a polished vacation bubble, Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is the stronger fit.

If your priority is a simpler hotel base in Montego Bay rather than a full-service all-inclusive resort, Hotel 39 Jamaica is the easier, more hotel-style choice.

Bottom line: choose Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica for an 18+ all-inclusive beach escape; choose Hotel 39 Jamaica if you want a less resort-driven Montego Bay stay.

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica vs Hotel 39 Jamaica – At a Glance

Category Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica Hotel 39 Jamaica
Overall Vibe Adults-only all-inclusive beachfront resort with a polished RIU Palace feel, infinity pools, swim-up bars, and a couples-or-friends atmosphere. More straightforward Montego Bay hotel stay for travelers who want a base without committing to a full all-inclusive resort experience.
Location On Mahoe Bay beach in Montego Bay, close to Sangster International Airport and set directly on the Caribbean Sea. In Montego Bay, making it a better fit for travelers who want a hotel-style stay in the destination rather than a secluded resort setup.
Rooms & Suites More than 200 rooms, including Junior Suites and Sea View whirlpool Suites, with free Wi-Fi and 24-hour room service included. Best viewed as a simpler hotel-room option for travelers who do not need resort-style suite perks or an all-inclusive room package.
Dining Main buffet plus à la carte Japanese, Italian, fusion, and steakhouse options, with bars including lobby, poolside, swim-up, and beach snack venues. Better if you prefer flexibility outside a resort dining plan and do not need multiple included restaurants as part of the stay.
Pools & Beach Direct Mahoe Bay beachfront access, white sand, calm shallow water, and three infinity pools, two with swim-up bars. A better match if your trip is less about a full beachfront pool-and-resort scene and more about using the hotel as a Montego Bay base.
Kids & Family Strictly adults-only, with an 18+ minimum age policy and no cribs or rollaway beds available. Choose only if its policies and setup fit your travel party; the brief does not establish it as an adults-only all-inclusive.
Price & Value Best value when you will use the all-inclusive package: dining, drinks, Wi-Fi, gym, pools, activities, and 24-hour room service. Best value if you do not need an all-inclusive resort and prefer paying for a simpler hotel stay in Montego Bay.

Rooms & Suites: Adults-Only Resort Comfort vs Simpler Hotel Base

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica – Room Style

Rooms at Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica fit the adults-only resort model: comfortable, service-driven, and tied into an all-inclusive stay with Wi-Fi and room service included.

  • More than 200 rooms, including Junior Suites and Sea View whirlpool Suites
  • Good for couples and friends who want a resort room connected to pools, beach, bars, and dining
  • Free Wi-Fi throughout the hotel and 24-hour room service included

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is the better pick if you want your room to be part of a complete adults-only all-inclusive resort experience.

Hotel 39 Jamaica – Room Style

Hotel 39 Jamaica is the better fit if you want a simpler hotel-style stay in Montego Bay instead of a larger adults-only all-inclusive resort.

  • Better for travelers who do not need an all-inclusive room package
  • A more flexible base-style choice for a Montego Bay trip
  • Best for guests who want the hotel stay to feel less resort-contained

If you are not looking for bundled dining, bars, beach amenities, and resort programming, Hotel 39 Jamaica may feel like the easier match.

Dining & Drinks: Included Resort Variety vs Independent Flexibility

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica – Restaurants & Bars

Dining at Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is a major reason to choose it, especially if you want the convenience of an all-inclusive plan with multiple restaurants and bars on site.

Expect:

  • Main buffet dining plus Japanese, Italian, fusion, and steakhouse options
  • Poolside, lobby, swim-up, and beach snack bar venues
  • Some à la carte dinner venues require reservations and formal dinner dress rules apply

Hotel 39 Jamaica – Restaurants & Bars

Hotel 39 Jamaica is the better choice if you do not want your meals and drinks to revolve around an all-inclusive resort plan.

  • Better for travelers who want more freedom outside a bundled dining setup
  • Good if you prefer a hotel base rather than a resort dining circuit
  • Ideal if included resort restaurants are not a priority

If included dining variety, swim-up bars, and room service matter most, Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica has the clear advantage.

Pools & Beach: Mahoe Bay Resort Scene vs Hotel-Base Stay

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica – Pool & Beach Scene

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is the stronger pool-and-beach pick, with direct Mahoe Bay beachfront access and a resort layout designed around the water.

  • Three infinity pools, including two with swim-up bars
  • Direct access to white sand and calm, shallow Mahoe Bay water
  • Best for adults who want a beach-resort vacation without leaving the property often

Hotel 39 Jamaica – Pool & Beach Scene

Hotel 39 Jamaica is better viewed as a Montego Bay hotel base rather than the pick for a full all-inclusive beachfront pool scene.

  • Better if a large resort pool complex is not essential
  • A fit for travelers who plan to use the hotel more lightly during the trip
  • Less suited to guests who want swim-up bars and a bundled beach-resort experience

If your vacation revolves around the beach, infinity pools, and swim-up bars, Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is the more complete choice.

Adults & Travel Style: 18+ All-Inclusive vs Flexible Hotel Stay

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica – Adults-Only Focus

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is strictly adults-only, with an 18+ minimum age policy and an atmosphere aimed at couples and friends rather than families.

  • Minimum check-in age is 18, with ID or passport verification expected
  • No cribs or rollaway beds are available
  • Best for adults who want a no-kids all-inclusive resort setting

Hotel 39 Jamaica – Travel Style

Hotel 39 Jamaica is the better fit for travelers who want a less all-inclusive, less resort-contained Montego Bay stay.

  • Better for guests who want a simpler hotel base
  • A better match if an adults-only resort atmosphere is not the main goal
  • Works best for travelers who want flexibility over bundled resort amenities

If the 18+ policy and all-inclusive beach-resort structure are central to your trip, Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is the safer match.

Price & Value: Which Montego Bay Stay Feels More Worth It?

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica – Value Snapshot

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica offers the most value when you plan to take full advantage of its all-inclusive setup and adults-only resort amenities.

  • Best for couples and friends who want meals, drinks, pools, and beach time built in
  • Strong value if you will use 24-hour room service, Wi-Fi, gym, and included activities
  • Worth it for adults who want a polished, self-contained Montego Bay resort stay

Hotel 39 Jamaica – Value Snapshot

Hotel 39 Jamaica is the better value if you do not need the cost or structure of an all-inclusive resort.

  • Best for travelers who want a simpler Montego Bay hotel stay
  • Stronger if you prefer flexibility over bundled resort dining and drinks
  • Worth considering if your trip is not centered on pools, beach service, and included amenities

Who Wins? Best Jamaica Stay by Travel Style

Best for Couples & Friends
Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica resort

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica

Choose Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica if you want an adults-only all-inclusive with direct Mahoe Bay beach access, infinity pools, swim-up bars, and multiple included dining options.

Best for Simpler Montego Bay Stays
Hotel 39 Jamaica resort

Hotel 39 Jamaica

Hotel 39 Jamaica is the better pick if you want a more straightforward Montego Bay hotel stay without the full all-inclusive resort structure.

Best for Beach, Pools & Swim-Up Bars
Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica resort

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica

For couples and friends who want a polished, 18+ resort atmosphere close to the beach and pools, Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica is the more complete vacation choice.

Best for Travelers Skipping the Resort Bubble
Hotel 39 Jamaica resort

Hotel 39 Jamaica

If you want a simpler base and do not need bundled restaurants, bars, 24-hour room service, and resort amenities, Hotel 39 Jamaica makes more sense.

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Hotel Riu Palace Jamaica

BOOK YOUR STAY NOW

Questions? Contact Us!

Close